Cup presented by W. H. MacDougall
| Year | Winner | Club | Venue |
| 1920 | J. H. Kirkwood | Riversdale (Vic.) | Hamilton |
| 1921 | E. S. Douglas | Miramar | Christchurch |
| 1922 | A. Ham | Wellington | Manawatu |
| 1923 | E. J. Moss | Auckland | Wanganui |
| 1924 | E. J. Moss | Auckland | Auckland |
| 1925 | E. J. Moss | Auckland | Christchurch |
| 1926 | J. McIntosh | Masterton | Miramar |
| 1927 | J. McIntosh | Masterton | Hamilton |
| 1928 | A. J. Shaw | Napier | Otago |
| 1929 | A. J. Shaw | Napier | Wanganui |
| 1930 | F. Rutter | Glendowie | Manawatu |
| 1931 | A. J. Shaw | (Unat.) Wanganui | Christchurch |
| 1932 | A. J. Shaw | (Unat.) Auckland | Wellington |
| 1933 | A. J. Shaw | (Unat.) Auckland | Titirangi |
| 1934 | A. J. Shaw | (Unat.) Wellington | Wanganui |
| 1935 | A. Murray | (Unat.) Auckland | Christchurch |
| 1936 | C. C. Clements | Russley | New Plymouth |
| 1937 | E. S. Douglas | Otago | Hamilton |
| 1938 | N. H. Fuller | (Unattached) Christchurch | Otago |
| 1939 | A. Murray | Titirangi | Miramar |
| 1940–45 | Not played during war | ||
| 1946 | A. J. Shaw | Hastings | Manawatu |
| 1947 | A. Murray | Titirangi | New Plymouth |
| 1948 | A. Murray | Titirangi | Otago |
| 1949 | R. H. Glading | Christchurch | Hastings |
| 1950 | E. A. Southerden | Napier | Christchurch |
| 1951 | R. A. Jackson | (Unattached) | Titirangi |
| 1952 | G. E. Hudson | Palmerston North | Wanganui |
| 1953 | P. W. Thomson | Victoria (Vic.) | Otago |
| 1954 | B. Crampton | Beverley Park (N.S.W.) | Wellington |
| 1955 | F. Phillips | Concord (N.S.W.) | Auckland |
| 1956 | J. Kelly | (Unattached) | Christchurch |
| 1957 | K. D. G. Nagle | Pymble (N.S.W.) | Manawatu |
| 1958 | K. D. G. Nagle | Pymble (N.S.W.) | Hamilton |
| 1959 | E. A. Southerden | Napier | Paraparaumu Beach |
| 1960 | K. D. G. Nagle | Pymble (N.S.W.) | Invercargill |
| 1961 | R. J. Charles | Christchurch | New Plymouth |
| 1962 | E. A. Southerden | Napier | Titirangi |
| 1963 | R. Tuohy | N.S.W. | Wanganui |
Co-creator
McLintock, Alexander Hare