Cup presented by Mr G. Brodie Breeze, Glasgow
| Year | Champion | Score | Club | Venue |
| 1907 | †A. D. S. Duncan | 159 | Wellington | Napier |
| 1908 | *J. A. Clements | 333 | Wanganui | Otago |
| 1909 | *J. A. Clements | 324 | Wanganui | Auckland |
| 1910 | A. D. S. Duncan | 295 | Wellington | Christchurch |
| 1911 | A. D. S. Duncan | 319 | Wellington | Wanganui |
| 1912 | *J. A. Clements | 321 | Christchurch | Wellington |
| 1913 | *E. S. Douglas | 303 | Nelson | Otago |
| 1914 | *E. S. Douglas | 313 | Wanganui | Auckland |
| 1915–18 | Not played during war | |||
| 1919 | *E. S. Douglas | 327 | Miramar | Napier |
| 1920 | *J. H. Kirkwood | 304 | Riversdale, Vic. | Hamilton |
| 1921 | *E. S. Douglas | 302 | Miramar | Christchurch |
| 1922 | *A. Brooks | 308 | Hutt | Manawatu |
| 1923 | *A. Brooks | 312 | Hutt | Wanganui |
| 1924 | *E. J. Moss | 301 | Auckland | Auckland |
| 1925 | E. M. Macfarlane | 308 | Christchurch | Christchurch |
| 1926 | *A. J. Shaw | 307 | Unattached, Wellington | Miramar |
| 1927 | *E. J. Moss | 300 | Auckland | Hamilton |
| 1928 | S. Morpeth | 303 | Maungakiekie | Otago |
| 1929 | *A. J. Shaw | 299 | Napier | Wanganui |
| 1930 | *A. J. Shaw | 284 | Napier | Manawatu |
| 1931 | *A. J. Shaw | 287 | Unattached | Christchurch |
| 1932 | *A. J. Shaw | 289 | Unattached, Auckland | Wellington |
| 1933 | *E. J. Moss | 300 | Auckland | Titirangi |
| 1934 | *A. J. Shaw | 288 | Unattached, Wellington | Wanganui |
| 1935 | *A. Murray | 286 | Unattached, Auckland | Christchurch |
| 1936 | *A. J. Shaw | 292 | Unattached, Wellington | New Plymouth |
| 1937 | J. P. Hornabrook | 299 | Manawatu | Hamilton |
| 1938 | *A. D. Locke | 288 | Unattached, Sth. Africa | Otago |
| 1939 | J P. Hornabrook | 291 | Masterton | Miramar |
| 1940–45 | Not played during war | |||
| 1946 | R. H. Glading | 306 | Hamilton | Manawatu |
| 1947 | R. H. Glading | 291 | Titirangi | New Plymouth |
| 1948 | *A. Murray | 294 | Titirangi | Otago |
| 1949 | *James Galloway | 283 | Unattached | Hastings |
| 1950 | *P. W. Thomson | 280 | Riversdale, Vic. | Christchurch |
| 1951 | *P. W. Thomson | 288 | Riversdale, Vic. | Titirangi |
| 1952 | * A. Murray | 293 | Unattached | Wanganui |
| 1953 | *P. W. Thomson | 295 | Victoria, Aust. | Otago |
| 1954 | R. J. Charles | 280 | Masterton | Wellington |
| 1955 | *P. W. Thomson | 280 | Victoria, Aust. | Auckland |
| 1956 | H. W. Berwick | 292 | St. Michael's, N.S.W. | Christchurch |
| 1957 | *K. D. G. Nagle | 294 | Pymble, N.S.W. | Manawatu |
| 1958 | *K. D. G. Nagle | 278 | Pymble, N.S.W. | Hamilton |
| 1959 | *P. W. Thomson | 287 | Victoria, Aust. | Paraparaumu Beach |
| 1960 | *P. W. Thomson | 281 | Victoria, Aust. | Invercargill |
| 1961 | *P. W. Thomson | 276 | Victoria, Aust. | New Plymouth |
| 1962 | *K. D. G. Nagle | 281 | Pymble, N.S.W. | Titirangi |
| 1963 | B. W. Devlin | 273 | N. S. Wales | Wanganui |
| 1964 | *K. D. G. Nagle | 266 | N. S. Wales | Christchurch |
*Denotes professional.
†In 1907 the “Open” was played over 36 holes; subsequent years, 72 holes.
Co-creator
McLintock, Alexander Hare