| 1932 | S. O. Hay (Sydenham) |
| 1933 | J. M. Carmichael (Hastings) |
| 1934 | T. Pritchard (Bulls) |
| 1935 | L. Hare (Hutt) |
| 1936 | R. H. Nicholl (Harbour Board, Wellington) |
| 1937 | T. Pritchard (Taumarunui) |
| 1938 | C. Bain (South Featherston) |
| 1939 | L. Hare (Hutt) |
| 1940 | D. McKenzie (Christchurch W.M.C.) |
| 1941 | L. Hare (Hutt) |
| 1942–46 | No competition |
| 1947 | S. L. Luxford (Hastings) |
| 1948 | E. S. Hughes (Wanganui Citizens) |
| 1949 | R. E. Taylor (Cashmere) |
| 1950 | E. White (Barnetts) |
| 1951 | E. White (Auckland) |
| 1952 | G. J. Perry (Ngaio) |
| 1953 | B. Weston (Palmerston North RSA) |
| 1954 | A. Crimp (Dunedin Railway) |
| 1955 | G. S. Hornung (Heathcote) |
| 1956 | C. Thom (Heathcote) |
| 1957 | A. Churcher (Municipal, Wanganui) |
| 1958 | T. Blomfield (Auckland) |
| 1959 | R. E. Taylor (Cashmere, Christchurch) |
| 1960 | R. E. Baker (Tauranga-Waikato) |
| 1961 | I. R. Ballinger (Sydenham) |
| 1962 | J. T. Hart (Marumaru) |
| 1963 | I. R. Ballinger (Sydenham) |
| 1964 | I. R. Ballinger (Sydenham) |
Co-creator
McLintock, Alexander Hare